eli manning hall of fame

We know Manning won two Super Bowl MVPs and has had his share of ups and downs during his time in New York. But the two Super Bowl wins were impressive.”, Anonymous voter 3: “Eli is a Hall of Famer in my mind because of the two Super Bowl victories. Lasting impressions mean something, and going backward Eli is 5-11, 3-12, 11-5, 6-10, 6-10, 7-9.”, Anonymous voter 13: “Stack up all the QBs of his era. The list of multiple Super Bowl MVP award winners reads like this: Hall of Famers Terry Bradshaw, Joe Montana and Bart Starr, arguably the greatest quarterback of all time in future Hall of Famer Tom Brady, and Manning. He also ranks in the top 10 of multiple key passing categories because his best ability was his durability. Seth Wickersham, senior writer: Yes, but he shouldn't be in on the first ballot. Everything that happens in New York is bigger.”, Kent Somers, Arizona Republic: “The two Super Bowls put him in rare company, but the overall win/loss record would be a factor for me and for many other voters, I suppose.”, Dave Birkett, Detroit Free Press: “I don't consider him the best quarterback playing at any time in his era, so he's not a slam dunk. He beat the greatest quarterback and coach of all time in two Super Bowls. While the answer to that for Manning might be no during the regular season (he has zero All-Pro selections), it changes in the postseason. I do hear and see -- a lot -- that he has never led the league in passing in any of his seasons. Ian O'Connor, senior writer: Yes. Two Super Bowl titles, two Super Bowl MVPs. Eli is going to Canton. ... I’m just not sure it’s Hall of Fame-worthy. Watching week-in and week-out, too often I did not see a Hall of Fame-worthy quarterback. You win two Super Bowls in New York -- both against the greatest coach-quarterback combination of the modern era -- you're in. (Fellow voter) Ron Borges likes to use the expression in our Hall of Fame meetings that it’s not just ability, but AVAIL-ability that is important in these discussions. Yes, two Super Bowls. And, ultimately, we judge pro quarterbacks on their ability to lead teams in postseason play. Sports for 'Watch Together' experience, Patrick Mahomes: Eli Manning's Super Bowl XLVI throw better than mine, It's time for Giants to move on from TE Evan Engram, Giants still have outside shot to win NFC East, Markus Golden thanks Giants, fans in post-trade goodbye, NFL keeping eye on Giants' investigation of Daniel Jones, Saquon Barkley, Ex-Giants Odell Beckham, Landon Collins suffer serious injuries in Week 7, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. “Not many players have done that. Or he will join Jim Plunkett as the only omitted quarterbacks with multiple Super Bowl wins. A finalist cannot afford more than nine “no” votes and Manning has at least 10 from the current committee members barring a change. Manning is a New England Patriots dynasty-killer, but he only went to the playoffs six times in 16 seasons. His Total QBR, a data-driven measure of overall quarterback play, ranks No. Retired New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning still has several years to wait before he finds himself enshrined in Canton, Ohio (and yes, that will happen), but he doesn’t have to wait that long to be enshrined in New Jersey. Could you write the history of the NFL without Eli? Dave Gettleman ran a double-reverse with Odell Beckham Jr., expressed a desire to only play for the Giants. Or are the Giants trying to save a 38-year-old fierce competitor — who has given no indication he wants to retire soon — from himself? NFL experts cast their votes, 49ers lose Samuel, Wilson for multiple weeks, Cowboys DC feels heat after hot sauce mishap, Source: Cards RB Drake likely out a few weeks, Seahawks' Carson week-to-week with foot sprain, Gase backs Darnold after QB's clunker vs. Bills, McCaffrey returns to practice field; status still iffy, 'Embarrassed' Cam admits job may be in jeopardy.

Cheap Copies Near Me, Newark Flight Status, Duplo Building Sets, Doogee S40 Sos Button, Raymond James Map, St Teresa Of Avila Timeline, Like A Charity Event Crossword Clue, God Of War Helios, Cher Chiquitita English, Summer Camp Lineup 2021, Andrew Peller News, Problem Statement Examples In Business Plan,